Welcome to SHOO-SHOO, RAH-RAH! The Duquesne Dukes Basketball Fan Message Board!
One of America's Great Message Boards - Any Inappropriate Posts Will Be Deleted! Posting on this Message Board is a privilege, not a right. No obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable material, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected is to be posted. All postings belong to the individual poster. Postings/posters may be deleted if found objectionable.
I started a new thread since the previous “Our Program” thread was closed. Levon, I salute your post and reasonableness. I disagree a bit on the coaching, but I am still a KD supporter. Now, bringing up the recruiting and player talent level is something I have been talking to some of my "cousins" about and was actually going to start a thread on that, but you beat me to the punch. LOL How does our talent level really stand up against the rest of the A-10 and especially the top tier? I would say we are probably somewhere in the middle at this point. I alluded to the recruiting, transfers and quality on another post and I am curious to hear the opinion of others. I am a bit surprised that we don't have anyone really pushing Marcus, Mike and even TDM at this point and they are here 4 years now - and yes I know they sat out a year - so to me that speaks to not attracting anyone of a higher talent level. I love Marcus, Mike and TDM (off the bench) and they turned out better than I expected, I am just saying usually you get higher caliber players over time and this is year 4 - notwithstanding COVID. Further, your point regarding Rotroff and Kelly is a good one as the injuries set them back and I really see a much higher upside with Kelly given his athleticism. So again, here are a couple fair questions. If we needed shooting (obviously), and Jett was a guy purportedly recruited to address this, why has he seen zero minutes - especially last game? Is it fair to then question the recruiting of him in the first place? What about Dre Harris? He was a legit 3 Star and our highest rated recruit (correct me if I am wrong, but I think GTown and some other bigger programs wanted him), but what do you guys think about his game? I am well aware it is early and we had the December from hell, but again you are right about a 2 year window that didn't seem to bear a lot of recruiting fruit - at least not yet. I am anxious to hear what everyone thinks and again good post Levon. I'm wondering if the plan from the beginning was to redshirt Jett. It coulld be that or his defense is lagging. Levon & Pistol good points. I look at Coach Dambrots interviews & he is clearly a beaten & frustrated coach. Due to Covid 19 the Cooper Center still on hold. No showers still playing on a 3rd court no familiarity for the players. Yeah he can give a Tomlinson .... “it is what it is”but he looks tired. My first concern is due to his age he does not get Covid. Yeah I screamed press against GW but he has won 400 games. 40 years without a bid to the big dance does as CLK has said fat old men. I am resigned to a disappointing season due to this curse upon the world. Dambrot the Prez & AD have done a great job. Stay healthy Coach it’s only a game. Go Dukes. If the Dukes beat Fordham, a doable possibility, they Sure, its very early, and we know that this team can win games on a level playing field. Sure, its very early, and we know that this team can win games on a level playing field. Yeah your right. No home court last two years. Limited practice facility. No lockers or showers. No opportunity to practice & see what the young kids can do. Play GW back to back by giving up home game. 3 games in 4 days with an out of shape team. Thank you for your analysis since Dambrot clearly is upbeat with this season. All of the things you mention Iron Duke are a result of the Covid pandemic; the lost practices and games; last minute schedule adjustments, failure to complete the Coop in time for the season. Nobody is “upbeat” about it but you just have to keep moving forward at whatever pace you can achieve. The motivation is that better times are on the way as the vaccines are distributed, the Coop is completed, the team has a home with showers, practices time increases. All of the things you mention Iron Duke are a result of the Covid pandemic; the lost practices and games; last minute schedule adjustments, failure to complete the Coop in time for the season. Nobody is “upbeat” about it but you just have to keep moving forward at whatever pace you can achieve. The motivation is that better times are on the way as the vaccines are distributed, the Coop is completed, the team has a home with showers, practices time increases. Gee whiz maybe I was right about reading Dambrot. I further suspect he was not blindsided by Austin & Carries game day decision. If you don’t want to be part of the program have a nice life to all three. Huggins fired 2 starters 2 years ago & went to the Big 12 final 4 with nothing left in the tank. Oscar T bolts Huggins says no loss. Yes they lost to Texas today last second shot but WVU will still compete in the NCAA tournament. If you have a diagnosis of cancer cut it out. This season was not right from the beginning. Move forward. Secondly, how do you quit before tip off? Need I say more Henry. As of March 11th 2020 everything was looking great for the program. The Dukes had once again exceeded preseason expectations despite having no home court and losing the best player from the 2018-2019 team due to yet another transfer. We had a shot at making the NIT with a deep run in the A10 tourney and who knows maybe we or someone else would knock off the Dayton juggernaut and we could sneak into the big dance. Then March 12th the world changed and the rest of the season was cancelled. As of March 11th 2020 everything was looking great for the program. The Dukes had once again exceeded preseason expectations despite having no home court and losing the best player from the 2018-2019 team due to yet another transfer. We had a shot at making the NIT with a deep run in the A10 tourney and who knows maybe we or someone else would knock off the Dayton juggernaut and we could sneak into the big dance. Then March 12th the world changed and the rest of the season was cancelled. Excellent post, S.R.M. I couldn't agree more with everything you stated. While things don't look nearly as rosy as they did before all this stuff happened, you have to take a look at these freshmen and realize the length and athleticism they have shown, albeit raw talent. I still believe Dambrot is the guy for this job and I think he is proving that the talent level will continue to increase as we go along. Remember, this program was one of the worst in the A10 for many, many years, if not the worst. Right now, it shows just how tough this league is with Duquesne improving its talent level under this coach and still only getting a fifth-place preseason pick. If you want to challenge for the top, the talent level has to continue to improve. If you look at guys like Okanyi and Baker, you can see a different type of player. I believe the coach, with the support and recruiting of his staff, will continue to find players like these guys and one day we are going to see a team emerge as a serious contender. Yep, if you don't want to be here because just maybe you're not the guy to take us there, then find a place that fits. And good luck, fellas. The change in the transfer rules has made it easier for players to leave a program It is definitely easier to transfer these days than any other time before this time period. The fact is we are losing too many players. Most players transfer because of playing time. The last four to transfer out was not because of playing time, they all started and were given a legitimate chance to prove themselves. Another reason is that they are not talented enough to play at this level. Players also transfer because they feel they can play at a higher level. The final two reasons are kids get home sick or they do not get along with the coaches. Last edited by Wildwood13 (1/10/2021 10:30 am) The change in the transfer rules has made it easier for players to leave a program It is a new wild cutthroat world of recruiting. Tampering, poaching, bug in ears by friendly people, which as been around for a long time, will be taken to new levels with less restrictions and greater economic incentives. .Coaches with businesses to run seem less and less likely to take a chance on unknown unrecruited players like Eric Williams and Sin Carry, only to develop them and see them leave. Coaches are going to just start backfilling and reloading with high level freshman recruits (if so lucky) or more likely measurable immediately eligible transfers to the best extent possible. It is definitely easier to transfer these days than any other time before this time period. The fact is we are losing too many players. Most players transfer because of playing time. The last four to transfer out was not because of playing time, they all started and were given a legitimate chance to prove themselves. Another reason is that they are not talented enough to play at this level. Players also transfer because they feel they can play at a higher level. The final two reasons are kids get home sick or they do not get along with the coaches. Kids from PA like Sincere and Maceo? It is definitely easier to transfer these days than any other time before this time period. The fact is we are losing too many players. Most players transfer because of playing time. The last four to transfer out was not because of playing time, they all started and were given a legitimate chance to prove themselves. Another reason is that they are not talented enough to play at this level. Players also transfer because they feel they can play at a higher level. The final two reasons are kids get home sick or they do not get along with the coaches. Kids from PA like Sincere and Maceo? No, kids from Philadelphia, and surrounding areas. That's where the talent is. KD's Great Lakes strategy will limit us. Recruit in the league's footprint. It is definitely easier to transfer these days than any other time before this time period. The fact is we are losing too many players. Most players transfer because of playing time. The last four to transfer out was not because of playing time, they all started and were given a legitimate chance to prove themselves. Another reason is that they are not talented enough to play at this level. Players also transfer because they feel they can play at a higher level. The final two reasons are kids get home sick or they do not get along with the coaches. Kids from PA like Sincere and Maceo? No, kids from Philadelphia, and surrounding areas. That's where the talent is. KD's Great Lakes strategy will limit us. Recruit in the league's footprint. That's true. It is quite frustrating to see a player like Fatts Russell play at URI (from Philly) not that I would like to have a volume shooter like that but it's an example. Of course the biggest modern example is Pittsburgh's Tre Mitchell at UMass. Yes he went to high school up there somewhere but he is a star. I wonder if Duquesne even crossed his mind. Last edited by BluffHunter (1/10/2021 3:26 pm) No, kids from Philadelphia, and surrounding areas. That's where the talent is. KD's Great Lakes strategy will limit us. Recruit in the league's footprint. That's true. It is quite frustrating to see a player like Fatts Russell play at URI (from Philly) not that I would like to have a volume shooter like that but it's an example. Of course the biggest modern example is Pittsburgh's Tre Mitchell at UMass. Yes he went to high school up there somewhere but he is a star. I wonder if Duquesne even crossed his mind. Sincere is from Ohio Also Maceo has a lot going on on his life. He gets a pass on his decision. I say Pa because we visit those areas and there is an extreme amount of talent in that area. So where does this leave Carry"s brother? This is really different...I know some folks who are upset or “worried” that the same old Duquesne is coming back. It isn’t. Transfers occur all over the country with all solid teams. No, kids from Philadelphia, and surrounding areas. That's where the talent is. KD's Great Lakes strategy will limit us. Recruit in the league's footprint. That's true. It is quite frustrating to see a player like Fatts Russell play at URI (from Philly) not that I would like to have a volume shooter like that but it's an example. Of course the biggest modern example is Pittsburgh's Tre Mitchell at UMass. Yes he went to high school up there somewhere but he is a star. I wonder if Duquesne even crossed his mind. Sincere is from Ohio Sin is from Farrell but moved in with the Bekeljas to Solon at some point in his childhood I believe he was about 11. I also wonder with Vickroy how Mike B feels about this. Last edited by BluffHunter (1/10/2021 5:13 pm) FAM, once again I am on the same page with you my friend. This is not the same old Duquesne. Now Vickroy asks a good question about the future of Sin's brother. My view, just based on talent level, is that MB was a real reach as he really didn't have any decent schools after him, which is why I too believe signing him was an attempt to keep Sin positive about being here. Again, nothing personal as he sounds like a good kid, but I just don't see how MB cuts it at the A-10 level. Remember we are looking to continually recruit even better players to get to the top of the league and ask does MB really fit that profile. Finally, I wish someone could get some intel on Jett R as all we are doing is speculating as to what is going on with him as well. If in fact the game at this level is too fast for him then he would probably be another transfer candidate. As Professor 1099 would say........time will tell. Pistol...correct on why Sincere's brother was signed. Now he has to make a decision. Stay and have a good college education at a good school, or leave and go somewhere else. Awh...um...Time - Will - Tell !!!!! FAM, once again I am on the same page with you my friend. This is not the same old Duquesne. Now Vickroy asks a good question about the future of Sin's brother. My view, just based on talent level, is that MB was a real reach as he really didn't have any decent schools after him, which is why I too believe signing him was an attempt to keep Sin positive about being here. Again, nothing personal as he sounds like a good kid, but I just don't see how MB cuts it at the A-10 level. Remember we are looking to continually recruit even better players to get to the top of the league and ask does MB really fit that profile. Finally, I wish someone could get some intel on Jett R as all we are doing is speculating as to what is going on with him as well. If in fact the game at this level is too fast for him then he would probably be another transfer candidate. As Professor 1099 would say........time will tell. My kid gets to listen to coach talk on the 21st I believe and afterward you can ask questions. He's invited me and if I get a question it will be about Jett.
CURRENT RECORD 9 - 14 (4-6 in the A-10)
Offline
Program 2
Wildwood made some valid and thoughtful points regarding the state of the program. His account of support from the Administration seems to be accurate to the best of our knowledge as outsiders.
In terms of recruiting and player retention the numbers aren’t pretty. I say this with the understanding that some of these players were probably given what amounts to a one year tryout to see if they can compete; so it might be understandable that there has been a lot of turnover. Unfortunately, I don’t think we’ve had enough “keepers” in our classes, resulting in a significant talent void between the first class of transfers and the present class of freshmen. Sin Carry and Maceo Austin are the only major contributors from those classes with Rotroff and Kelly hoping to contribute off the bench. Of course both of them suffered ACL tears that have interfered with their progress. I’m still hoping that one of those guys can raise his level of play to replace some of the production lost by Bailey Steele; who understood the game and was a key performer last season.
The major hole in recruiting over the last four years has been the failure to secure a strong 2-guard who is a legitimate A-10 player. They took a shot with Lamar; but he couldn’t get it done and is now moving on. I like TDM providing a spark off the bench and backing up Sin Carry at the point; but finding that guy who can score and defend at the 2-spot is a priority.
I have to break with Wildwood however on his criticism of in-game decisions; I.e. coach should have pressed in a certain game etc.... I understand that people like to criticize strategy and that’s anyone’s prerogative on an open forum; but I’m not going there; especially in this particular season. I’ll concede that the coaches know more about their team, their opponent and game situations than we will ever hope to know; so although I’ve coached and been a student of the game for many years; I’m not going there!
Finally, in regard to this Covid-ravaged Duquesne season; I think we should be as respectful and supportive of the players and coaches as possible. They are in a very bad spot right now trying to put together a competitive team on a very uneven playing field. Playing Conference games without practice or conditioning against teams that have in some cases been only mildly affected by Covid is a daunting task. Let’s try to be positive!
Offline
Re: Program 2
Offline
Re: Program 2
Offline
Re: Program 2
Offline
Re: Program 2
will be 3-3 overall and 2-2 conference
VCU top of the league at 3-0 but with the virus who knows what could happen to VCU
STL had yet to play a conference game.
KD has said that he is looking at the long view.
We need patience because of the virus.
I am happy they are playing at all and so far
no serious health problems.
If the Dukes can stay at 500 and spurt in February
I think we could have a good season.
Offline
Re: Program 2
As for KD, I thought he looked pretty good and healthy in his post-game presser after Davidson. I'm sure he is frustrated with the conditions you mentioned, but I think it's a bit of an over-reaction to say he looks like a beaten man. I'm no seeing that at all. •
Thread Starter
Offline
Re: Program 2
levon1975 wrote:
As for KD, I thought he looked pretty good and healthy in his post-game presser after Davidson. I'm sure he is frustrated with the conditions you mentioned, but I think it's a bit of an over-reaction to say he looks like a beaten man. I'm no seeing that at all.
Offline
Re: Program 2
•
Thread Starter
Offline
Re: Program 2
levon1975 wrote:
Offline
Re: Program 2
Still as of 11/29/20 the future of the program was looking better than it had at anytime in the last few decades. We had 7 of our 8 primary contributors coming back and for the first time in a while no one who mattered transferred. Then we lost to Little Rock and I was surprised but not concerned I thought good teams lose early in the year to inferior teams all the time in college basketball nothing to worry about. 3 days later we soundly beat a decent UNCG team and I thought ok now all is well. Next thing you know just about the entire team gets COVID-19 and we don't play for a month. The GW games were cause for concern but I was hoping it was just COVID fatigue and a lack of practice time. Then prior to the Davidson game I hear Lamar is transferring. I think darn there goes not losing any transfers but we have depth and Lamar, while a nice piece, was far from irreplaceable. The Davidson game was maybe the ugliest of the Dambrot era something seemed wrong. Now Carry and Austin are gone and we just played terribly against the worst team in the league. To say I'm concerned would be an understatement.
With that said, I have confidence in Keith Dambrot because he has a two decade track record of success. If you don't want to be here see you later.
The freshman look very promising and I honestly think they have more upside than those who departed because they are long and athletic. Maybe they develop nicely throughout the rest of the season and we get lucky and Mike, Marcus and Tavian take the extra year and come back. Next year we can be right back in th position we were in on 11/29/20 with a solid core back from a team that showed they could compete in the Atlantic 10.
Offline
Re: Program 2
S.R.M. wrote:
Still as of 11/29/20 the future of the program was looking better than it had at anytime in the last few decades. We had 7 of our 8 primary contributors coming back and for the first time in a while no one who mattered transferred. Then we lost to Little Rock and I was surprised but not concerned I thought good teams lose early in the year to inferior teams all the time in college basketball nothing to worry about. 3 days later we soundly beat a decent UNCG team and I thought ok now all is well. Next thing you know just about the entire team gets COVID-19 and we don't play for a month. The GW games were cause for concern but I was hoping it was just COVID fatigue and a lack of practice time. Then prior to the Davidson game I hear Lamar is transferring. I think darn there goes not losing any transfers but we have depth and Lamar, while a nice piece, was far from irreplaceable. The Davidson game was maybe the ugliest of the Dambrot era something seemed wrong. Now Carry and Austin are gone and we just played terribly against the worst team in the league. To say I'm concerned would be an understatement.
With that said, I have confidence in Keith Dambrot because he has a two decade track record of success. If you don't want to be here see you later.
The freshman look very promising and I honestly think they have more upside than those who departed because they are long and athletic. Maybe they develop nicely throughout the rest of the season and we get lucky and Mike, Marcus and Tavian take the extra year and come back. Next year we can be right back in th position we were in on 11/29/20 with a solid core back from a team that showed they could compete in the Atlantic 10.
Offline
Re: Program 2
as we see with the three that have left.
But it also makes it easier for the Dukes to recruit unhappy 4 star players on P 5 schools.
KD had the depth through what we thought was overbooking. No one understood why all the players. I wonder if KD anticipated what has happened and recruited the freshmen players as a hedge.
Offline
Re: Program 2
So we have to examine why players choose schools. I figure there are three reasons, first a solid winning program. Unfortunately over the past forty years, except for a few years, Duquesne would not be considered one of these programs. Secondly players choose a school because of the relationship with the coach. As far as I can see, so far that would only be three players. They would be Marcus, TDM and Michael H. Those three seem like they would go through a brick wall for Dambrot. When they play, they seem to enjoy themselves on the court, which I mentioned in a previous thread is very important. The final reason they choose a school is because of the institution itself and its location.
What do we do? For starters let’s start recruiting kids in PA, after all that’s what turned PSU around. The Ohio and Michigan kids have enough colleges to choose from in the Mid American and Big Ten. Let’s look for players that want to go to Duquesne because they like our business, law, pharmacy or any of the health science schools. And finally let’s get the kids that enjoy playing for our coach !!
Offline
Re: Program 2
Econ69 wrote:
as we see with the three that have left.
But it also makes it easier for the Dukes to recruit unhappy 4 star players on P 5 schools.
KD had the depth through what we thought was overbooking. No one understood why all the players. I wonder if KD anticipated what has happened and recruited the freshmen players as a hedge.
Offline
Re: Program 2
Wildwood13 wrote:
So we have to examine why players choose schools. I figure there are three reasons, first a solid winning program. Unfortunately over the past forty years, except for a few years, Duquesne would not be considered one of these programs. Secondly players choose a school because of the relationship with the coach. As far as I can see, so far that would only be three players. They would be Marcus, TDM and Michael H. Those three seem like they would go through a brick wall for Dambrot. When they play, they seem to enjoy themselves on the court, which I mentioned in a previous thread is very important. The final reason they choose a school is because of the institution itself and its location.
What do we do? For starters let’s start recruiting kids in PA, after all that’s what turned PSU around. The Ohio and Michigan kids have enough colleges to choose from in the Mid American and Big Ten. Let’s look for players that want to go to Duquesne because they like our business, law, pharmacy or any of the health science schools. And finally let’s get the kids that enjoy playing for our coach !!
Offline
Re: Program 2
BluffHunter wrote:
Wildwood13 wrote:
So we have to examine why players choose schools. I figure there are three reasons, first a solid winning program. Unfortunately over the past forty years, except for a few years, Duquesne would not be considered one of these programs. Secondly players choose a school because of the relationship with the coach. As far as I can see, so far that would only be three players. They would be Marcus, TDM and Michael H. Those three seem like they would go through a brick wall for Dambrot. When they play, they seem to enjoy themselves on the court, which I mentioned in a previous thread is very important. The final reason they choose a school is because of the institution itself and its location.
What do we do? For starters let’s start recruiting kids in PA, after all that’s what turned PSU around. The Ohio and Michigan kids have enough colleges to choose from in the Mid American and Big Ten. Let’s look for players that want to go to Duquesne because they like our business, law, pharmacy or any of the health science schools. And finally let’s get the kids that enjoy playing for our coach !!
Offline
Re: Program 2
duq81 wrote:
BluffHunter wrote:
Wildwood13 wrote:
So we have to examine why players choose schools. I figure there are three reasons, first a solid winning program. Unfortunately over the past forty years, except for a few years, Duquesne would not be considered one of these programs. Secondly players choose a school because of the relationship with the coach. As far as I can see, so far that would only be three players. They would be Marcus, TDM and Michael H. Those three seem like they would go through a brick wall for Dambrot. When they play, they seem to enjoy themselves on the court, which I mentioned in a previous thread is very important. The final reason they choose a school is because of the institution itself and its location.
What do we do? For starters let’s start recruiting kids in PA, after all that’s what turned PSU around. The Ohio and Michigan kids have enough colleges to choose from in the Mid American and Big Ten. Let’s look for players that want to go to Duquesne because they like our business, law, pharmacy or any of the health science schools. And finally let’s get the kids that enjoy playing for our coach !!
Offline
Re: Program 2
BluffHunter wrote:
duq81 wrote:
BluffHunter wrote:
Kids from PA like Sincere and Maceo?
Offline
Re: Program 2
Offline
Re: Program 2
Offline
Re: Program 2
-We have a proven coaching staff with experience
-We have an excellent AD
-We have a University President who backs the basketball program
Things will work out...in fact I believe they will be even better. Go Dukes!
Offline
Re: Program 2
Wildwood13 wrote:
BluffHunter wrote:
duq81 wrote:
Offline
Re: Program 2
Pistol out..
Offline
Re: Program 2
Go Dukes
Offline
Re: Program 2
PistolPete wrote:
Pistol out..
BOARD ADMINISTRATIVE PARAMETERS:
-The comments & opinions on this fan message board are owned by their authors & we make no representation of their fitness, accuracy, and are held harmless.
-This is an independent fan board not affiliated with Duquesne University.
-This fan message board is for YOUR enjoyment (even if it's not a good year!)
We want to thank everyone for their continued love and support for Duquesne University Basketball. GO DUKES!